HOME SHARED LETTERS RATINGS MY PLANET COMMUNITIES MISSION SIGN UP!
Shared Letters

Join and browse our exclusive open discussion forums and talk about whatever you like.

Channels
» The Suggestion Box
» Company Responses
» PFB Feedback Line
» Consumer Podcasts
» Mommy Talk & Daddy Dialogue ™
» Shared Letters


Newsletter

Sign up for PlanetFeedback's "Consumer Café" email newsletter!





Misled by the Meriden Humane Society

Posted Fri August 19, 2011 12:00 pm, by Susan R.


On August 4, 2011, my husband and I, along with our two young nieces went to the Meriden Humane Society to adopt a dog. My husband has wanted a dog for a very long time, but we needed to find one who would be a good fit for our home as we have a 4-year-old cat and our nieces and nephew are around our house often. We started by reviewing the shelter's large book of pets available for adoption. Each animal photo is accompanied by a description of the dog, his/her temperament and a warning if the dog cannot be around other dogs, cats, children or other environments.

We came across a listing for a Dogo Argentinium by the name of Casper. His listing carried no such warnings mentioned earlier, and was said to be of excellent temperament. We were told by a volunteer that he had been in a family that had to move and was forced to leave him behind in the care of the humane society. We asked to meet him and in the presence of the volunteer, Jenn, we played with him, walked him a bit and got to know him. We met the director of the humane society, who was excited that we were interested in Casper. We filled out an application, which included references and the name of our cat's veteranarian. We were told that our application would be reviewed and that a home visit would be scheduled to be sure that our environment would be suitable for Casper. In addition, Jenn advised us that because we already own a cat, Casper would be part of a "cat interaction," whereby he would be placed in a room with cats who are also residing in the shelter to gauge his reactions to them.

The next day, August 5, we returned to the shelter again with our nieces. We brought a rope toy, a blanket and some training treats. We spent a significant amount of time bonding with Casper and we were told by Jenn that he had done well in the cat interaction, showing no aggression and allowing the cats to be near him. When we left, we took the blanket so we could allow the cat to become accustomed to Casper's scent. Later that same afternoon, we received a call from Jenn, who stated that she wanted to conduct the home visit that day. We agreed to this and Jenn arrived at our home with her mother that afternoon. During the home visit, Jenn advised us that we had a wonderful home and neighborhood for Casper, that our cat looked very nice and healthy and that our vet had given them very satisfactory information. She advised us that she would write a very positive report and that the director would contact us within 2-3 days with her decision, which Jenn was sure would be in our favor.

On Sunday, August 7, we returned to the shelter to visit with Casper. A volunteer (not Jenn) welcomed us and said she would send the director out to speak with us. The director never came outside. We didn't think much of this and returned Casper to the volunteer when we were ready to leave.

On Tuesday, August 9, when we hadn't yet received a phone call from the director, my husband called the humane society and left a voicemail requesting a callback. No callback was received.

On Thursday, August 11, after receiving still no response, my husband left another voicemail at the humane society. He then called an alternate number he had been given, not realizing that it was Jenn's personal cell phone number. She answered and was extremely surprised that we hadn't yet been contacted by the director. She stated that she couldn't understand why it would be taking so long, but that she would speak with the director and have her call us. No callback was ever received.

On Friday, August 12 (a full week since the home visit), we sent an email to the humane society, explaining the situation and requesting a call or a return email. No call or return email ever took place.

On Saturday, August 13, we visited the humane society in person, to find that there was an adoption event taking place. We asked one of the volunteers if we could speak with the director, and she got on a walkie talkie to let her know we were there. The director never came out to see us. We instead spoke with another woman who stated that she worked with the director. We spoke with her about the situation. She said she couldn't help us due to the event that was currently taking place; that the humane society was closed for business. She wrote down mine and my husband's phone number and said she would call us the next day. As we were leaving the humane society, we saw the director, who purposely turned from us and ignored us.

On Sunday, August 14, we received a call from a young volunteer that we had never before worked with. She stated that she was sorry, but it had been decided that Casper didn't do well with cats and we would not be allowed to adopt him. Upon trying to ask her why this was not told to us before, and in fact, why we had been told exactly the opposite, she had no answers.

I do not know the real and true reason that we were not allowed to adopt Casper. Were we lied to from the beginning, or at the end? We are very disappointed in this outcome, as we had bonded with Casper and had begun preparing our home for his arrival based on the positive information we had received from the director on our first visit and from Jenn before, during and after our home visit.

My husband and I would like a truthful explanation for this adoption gone wrong. We are loving and responsible pet owners and we support shelter adoptions; but we feel we were misled, ignored in the hope that we would go away, and then lied to in an attempt to make us go away. We hope that Casper and all the animals at this shelter go to loving homes. We will be going elsewhere to open ours to a needy animal.


Reply



Log In/Create an account | 19 comments
     Add to your del.icio.us  del.icio.us    Digg this story  Digg this  
PlanetFeedback Comments are subject to strict terms and conditions. We reserve the right to deny site membership privileges to any individuals acting inappropriately.
by undercover Posted Tue October 2, 2012 @ 11:51 PM

Marlena lies a lot is a control freak MHS is her very own hoarder
situation never calls people bsck is the only person who can
approve antything. Does not delegate. Money donated unaccounted for
Donated cameras disappear She answers to no one and animals miss
out on good home because she cant do it all, will not accept help, and
applications sit in piles unreviewed and people not called back
place needs new director and board that will really do whst is best
for animals and not M's ego. Dogs sit in cagesvfor years

Reply

by TortieKitty Posted Wed August 24, 2011 @ 10:44 AM

Hello, everyone.

Wanted to stop by and give you an update. We received a call from the
director of this shelter. She apologized for what happened and
informed us that the volunteer who called us to let us know we were
not approved for Casper should've gone on to say that we were approved
as adopters for another dog or cat of our choosing, if we wish.
Apparently, although Casper did well in the interaction with the
shelter cats, he didn't do so well when he spent the night at the home
of a shelter volunteer who has two cats of her own. Based on some
aggression he showed in the home environment, they didn't feel it
appropriate to send him into our home with a cat, and under those
circumstances, I certainly agree. As of today, Casper is still
available for adoption.

We have completed an adoption with the Meriden Humane Society for a
2-year-old Shih Tzu mix who was brought to the shelter more recently.
We are excited that we will be able to bring him home today or
tomorrow.

Reply


Great news! by PsychoSekc Wed August 24, 2011 @ 1:11 PM


O good. I'm glad you got a doggy - and I'm glad they were considerate enough to be thinking of you like that by PepperElf Wed August 24, 2011 @ 2:56 PM


oh good! by fairywithfangs Wed August 24, 2011 @ 8:12 PM

Lucky dog! by cissy Thu August 25, 2011 @ 11:15 AM

by PepperElf Posted Tue August 23, 2011 @ 11:14 AM

Well it could be several things...


as suggested below, it's possible that someone else wanted the dog and
they don't want to tell you the truth about it.


OR it could be that the dog worked well with cats at first but then
something else happened which would make the dog a bad fit for you.




Now personally if it was the latter, I'd rather not even take the
animal home... cos what if it was the truth and doggy decided your cat
was a chew toy?



As for breed temperament... no idea. Never heard of this breed before.
However I do know my boyfriend would love to have a dog. and that
whatever breed we get, he'll be stuffing my brain full of info on what
the breed is like etc... because if it's not a breed he's familiar
with he'll learn up on it.


but even then, breed tendencies might not matter much. like
greyhounds. we thought about them for a while but can't get them for
this apartment. (too big) They're traditionally hunting animals and
athletes. so some will want to chase Kitty until kitty's heart
explodes (same way they hunt rabbit... case it until the heart blows
up). However not all greyhounds are like that. some like cats just
fine, others don't.

Usually however with the greyhound adoption group it will state "cats,
no cats, or untested".



And with ANY dog - if the warning isn't listed, I'd recommend going
with "UNTESTED". I wouldn't consider it to be an actual "safe" unless
it's specifically listed as such.

Reply


Actually... by Harleycat Wed August 24, 2011 @ 10:23 AM


It's the size. They have a strict weight limit for dogs by PepperElf Wed August 24, 2011 @ 2:59 PM


by McJohn Posted Tue August 23, 2011 @ 10:35 AM

Without knowing exactly what happened you might just want to look at
this as a good thing.

If the Dog (casper) had done something while they were Cat testing
him, like fight with the cat, or bit him etc. They may have decided
not to put him in a home with a cat.

The last thing you want is a new dog and a wounded or dead cat as a
result.

Reply
by Jared C. Posted Mon August 22, 2011 @ 11:12 AM

This letter is very sad. I'm sorry you weren't able to adopt Casper.

Based on your detailed letter, I do not see any reason why you were
denied the chance to give him a forever home.

Thank you for being good people in your willingness to adopt animals
from shelters. Despite the poor experience you had with this shelter,
please do not sour on all shelters. They are truly the best place to
find a loving companion animal.

I adopted my cat Sami from the local SPCA and he has been the best cat
I ever could have wished for.

Reply

by Dana G. Posted Mon August 22, 2011 @ 11:05 AM

How sad. I recently went through a similar situation. I was able to
go to my local SPCA and adopt an adorable kitten. I found that
everything truly does happen for a reason. If I hadn't had my sad
experience, I would not have ever met Santino and wouldn't have gotten
to share my home with such a wonderful cat. Wishing you the best -
try your local SPCA!

Reply


Another possibility..... by PsychoSekc Sun August 21, 2011 @ 6:58 PM


either i am missing it by fairywithfangs Mon August 22, 2011 @ 7:56 AM

by PsychoSekc Posted Mon August 22, 2011 @ 8:48 AM

Dogs are large and muscular doesn't mean they were bred for the same
purpose, same temperment nor same traits. For example, the Dogo
Argentino was bred for hunting game including boar and puma. It can be
dog aggressive and it has a high prey drive(something you want to be
very careful with since you have a cat). Compare it to a Rottweiler,
which is another large muscular breed, which was bred to be a cattle
droving dog and to pull carts. They have nothing in common which is
why it's important to be educated on the breed before you bring one
home.

Anyways, I do agree that they handled the situation wrong and they
should've been honest with you as to what happened with the dog and/or
why they did not place it with you. If anything, if you're interested
in a large breed of dog, especially if you have children around and
other pets, your best bet may be to contact breed specific rescue.
These folks are more experienced with their chosen breed and can help
you find the appropriate dog for your family.

Personally speaking, I've had various issues with rescue, which turned
me off to it and I ended up getting my dog from a responsible breeder,
so I wouldn't rule out a good breeder as well. Good luck in your
search.

Reply

by MA Cunningham Posted Tue August 23, 2011 @ 10:50 AM

OK, if the rescue people came and snatched up the dog, then that is
even MORE ignorant. Why would they assume that they know more or
better if this family is compatible? That's a little shortsighted,
IMHO.

To read the description of the dog, it was deliberately bred to be a
COMPATIBLE dog in hunting with other dogs. I can't imagine it being
aggressive with a cat that is IN THE HOME (since they are supposed to
be protective of their families) and then using that as a reason to
deny the adoption.

But overall, I believe that this organization handled themselves
unprofessionally. The very LEAST the director could have done was
speak to them. That is what she is PAID to do.

I'm really getting worried about adopting a shelter animal in the next
year or so if this is what I have to look forward to!

My God! I wasnt even scrutinized this extensively when I had my kids,
and they do home visits, TO PLACE A DOG???

Reply


..... by PsychoSekc Tue August 23, 2011 @ 6:50 PM

by RedheadwGlasses Posted Sat August 20, 2011 @ 3:17 PM

Honestly, I think they probably adopted the dog to someone else --
possibly an employee or volunteer -- and just are lying to cover their
tracks. I'm sorry they treated you this way. I have a lot of respect
for the work that animal lovers do for pets that need homes, but so
many of these shelters are just ridiculous and absolutely hinder the
process.

I say this with one rescue cat, almost 17, dozing on her shelf,
another rescue cat sleeping on my bed, and another sitting on my lap
purring right now (and she doesn't even like me that much, but she
sure loves a lap when I'm at the computer).

I've adopted numerous cats and a dog and never had to jump through
hoops except for one cat who was retarded or brain damaged in some
way. They wanted to make sure that he went to a home with no kids and
that EXTRA precautions would be taken to keep him from going outside.
Given his lack of normal cat sense and intelligence, descriving the
excessive amount of doors in our home, we got him over another family
with a kid.

Reply

by fairywithfangs Posted Fri August 19, 2011 @ 9:44 PM

I'm really sorry you went through all that - as a pet owner and animal
lover myself it seems very unfair that the shelter would allow you to
do so much bonding with the dog only to not return your calls or let
you know what was going on. I do hope you get a proper explanation. I
have been turned down by shelters and it can be a big blow especially
after you have your heart set on one. I do feel that some shelters
can be a little extreme in the screening processes. I understand why
they do all they do but feel as though they are allowing some of the
animals to miss out on some wonderful families. good luck!

Reply




Home | Shared Letters | Ratings | Login | Communities | Categories | RSS | Contact Us | Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy | FAQ
Copyright 2013 © All Rights Reserved PlanetFeedback.com | Web by Cicada